Judge drops false statements case against ex-FBI officials
A federal judge in Washington, D.C., ruled the government failed to prove two former counterintelligence leaders lied to Congress about the Hunter Biden probe.
By Daphne Turner ·

U.S. Magistrate Judge Zia Faruqui dismissed the criminal complaint against two former senior FBI officials on Monday, concluding the government lacked the evidence to prove they lied to Congress. Faruqui ruled that Nikki Floris and Bradley Benavides did not commit a crime, ending a case that critics argued was timed to influence the November midterm elections.
The judge described the prosecution as "slapdash" and stated there was no direct evidence or clear motive for the defendants' actions. "Without motive, without direct evidence, I have nothing," Faruqui said from the bench. "It is not close. It is nothing." He added that the events could be described as nothing other than weaponization.
The case centered on testimony provided by Floris and Benavides to the House Judiciary Committee in 2023. Prosecutors alleged the pair made false statements regarding an FBI counterintelligence operation known as Round River. That effort aimed to identify derogatory reports about Hunter Biden and flag them as potential Russian disinformation. Floris served as the deputy assistant director of the Foreign Influence Task Force, while Benavides was its section chief.
FBI Special Agent Bryan Witt testified that the investigation began one day after President Donald Trump accused intelligence officials of hiding a Chinese interference coverup in July 2025. Witt noted that senior FBI officials, including Director Kash Patel, monitored the case closely. He also acknowledged that colleagues in his Kansas City field office feared the probe was a witch hunt.
The judge found that the government failed to meet the three legal requirements for a false statements charge: the statements must be false, made knowingly and willfully, and material to the investigation. Faruqui cited a taped conversation where Carlton Davis, a special counsel, admitted the team had made a "f***-up" by failing to interview key congressional staffers who witnessed the testimony.
A Justice Department spokesperson said the agency disagrees with the decision and is evaluating all options, including appealing to the chief judge or seeking a grand jury indictment. The spokesperson stated the department's actions are guided by facts and law, not politics. Faruqui noted that the timing of the charges in October 2026 coincided with no other major legal deadlines, leading him to question the motive behind the rush to charge.
Floris and Benavides were flanked by former FBI and Justice Department officials after the ruling, including former Acting FBI Director Brian Driscoll. Margaret Donovan, one of Floris' attorneys, called the complaint a "spaghetti at the wall" effort. Faruqui warned that the case would have a chilling effect on congressional testimony and erode public confidence in the Justice Department.
More Business · Business Complaints · Report a business · Got a Story?






