Trial centers on 26-minute window where phone stopped moving
Federal prosecutors argue a detective strangled a pregnant woman in that interval, while the defense claims she was already struggling with mental health issues.
By Sergio Ramirez ·

Federal prosecutors have presented a timeline that isolates a 26-minute window during which Sandra Birchmore’s phone ceased moving, a period they say covers the time her detective boyfriend killed her. The trial of Matthew Farwell, a former Stoughton police detective, hinges on this specific digital evidence and the state’s initial failure to investigate his presence at the scene. Jurors are reviewing text messages and security footage that place Farwell in Birchmore’s apartment from 9:14 p.m. to 9:40 p.m. on February 1, 2021.
The case originated in 2021 when a tipster reported Farwell’s relationship with Birchmore. Stoughton police initially concluded the death was a suicide after interviewing Farwell for only 15 minutes in a parking lot. Federal investigators later determined that detectives did not examine Farwell for injuries or collect his DNA before he deleted his texts with Birchmore. The FBI took over the case in 2023 after Brian Holmes, a former deputy chief at the Stoughton Police Department, raised concerns about the initial handling.
Farwell, 40, faces charges of killing Birchmore and staging the scene to conceal a sexual relationship that began when she was 15. Prosecutors argue he murdered her to prevent her from revealing the relationship to his wife. An expert for the federal government, Dr. William Smock, testified that Birchmore was strangled with a duffel bag strap and showed signs of struggling. The state’s medical examiner has since changed the official cause of death from suicide to undetermined.
Text messages read into evidence show the dynamics of their relationship. In one 2020 exchange, Birchmore described April 10, 2013, as the best day of her life, referencing when they first had sex. She was 15, and Farwell was 27. Later messages revealed Farwell discussing violent fantasies involving choking. After Birchmore confirmed her pregnancy in late 2020, Farwell responded that he had nothing to say. When she suggested he be present for the birth, he called her the worst person on the face of the earth.
Defense attorney Kimberly Stevens argues that Birchmore was a troubled individual who began psychiatric medication at age six. Stevens told jurors that Farwell visited the apartment to break up with Birchmore, not to kill her. She noted that Birchmore had less than $3 in the bank and was alone for the holidays. Stevens emphasized that Farwell made regrettable mistakes but is not a killer.
A paternity test determined that Jason Pickard, an Army recruiter, was the biological father of the unborn child. Pickard testified that he met Birchmore in 2019 and that she told him Farwell was the father. Prosecutors contend that Farwell realized he had lost control of the situation and needed to silence Birchmore permanently. Assistant U.S. Attorney Torey Cummings told jurors that the death was a matter of when the crimes would be exposed, not if.
The FBI’s review included a look at the original investigation, where a lead investigator told Farwell’s twin brother, Billy Farwell, that he wanted the case closed like he needed a bullet in the head. Billy Farwell testified that the investigator was a family friend. The federal case now tests whether that early decision to close the file obscured the truth.
Prosecutors finished their presentation on Wednesday. The defense is scheduled to call witnesses on Friday for a third day of testimony. The case may go to the jury as early as the following week.
The trial takes place in federal court in Boston. Farwell’s legal team is challenging the original police narrative that relied on the detective’s word and a quick closure of the file. The digital forensics evidence regarding the phone’s location remains the central piece of physical evidence in the proceedings.
More Business · Business Complaints · Report a business · Got a Story?






