AdvertiseDonate
Wednesday, November 18, 2026Local news for Dallas County, Texas.
Dallas County Herald · 3838 Oak Lawn Avenue, Suite 1000, Dallas, TX 75219
News · Atlanta

Jury Deliberates in Police Homicide Case

The panel began reviewing evidence on Friday in the trial of Matthew Farwell, who prosecutors say killed a pregnant woman to hide a past affair.

By Daphne Turner ·

Illustration for: Jury Deliberates in Police Homicide Case
Illustration generated for this article, not a news photograph.

Federal jurors began deliberations on Friday in the case of Matthew Farwell, a former Massachusetts police detective accused of murdering Sandra Birchmore to conceal a sexual relationship that began when she was a minor.

Prosecutors argue that Farwell strangled Birchmore in her Stoughton apartment on February 1, 2021, after learning she was pregnant. Assistant U.S. Attorney Brian Fogerty told the jury that Farwell did not visit to start over but to fix a mistake that could have led to serious charges. He described the act as a way to eliminate the threat of being exposed for an affair that began when Birchmore was 15 and Farwell was 27.

The defense maintains that Farwell did not kill Birchmore and that they did not have sex until she reached the legal age of consent in Massachusetts. Attorney Kimberly Stevens suggested that Birchmore, who had threatened suicide in the past, may have taken her own life after Farwell visited her apartment to end the relationship. Stevens asked the jury to consider whether a person in such a state would call for help or use a belt to stop the pain.

Initial local investigators concluded the death was a suicide after finding Birchmore on the floor with a belt around her neck. The state medical examiner later changed the cause of death to undetermined. The FBI opened its own investigation in 2023 after finding flaws in the local inquiry. Federal agents noted that Farwell was questioned for only 15 minutes in a parking lot and that his phone was checked only after he had deleted messages with Birchmore.

Forensic experts provided conflicting testimony during the month-long trial. Dr. William Smock, hired by the prosecution, said the injuries indicated Birchmore was strangled with a canvas bag belt and fought back. He noted her glasses were missing from the scene and her sandals were overturned. Dr. Thomas Andrew, the defense expert, rejected the conclusion that the death was a homicide.

Text messages recovered by the FBI revealed about 40,000 exchanges between the two, including references to their past encounters and Birchmore’s desire for a child. A paternity test performed after her death showed the father was another man. A friend reported the romance to the Stoughton police twelve days before Birchmore died.

More News · Report a business · Got a Story?

Get Dallas County Herald in your inboxLocal news for Dallas County, Texas. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.

Get Dallas County Herald in your inboxLocal news for Dallas County, Texas. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.