Bradenton Beach Home Construction Halted Over Missing Permit
A stop work order issued in October halted a project that had already passed ten inspections, prompting a dispute over which city official issued the initial approval.
By Salma Farouk ·

Construction on a new home at 1207 Gulf Drive South in Bradenton Beach stopped on Oct. 2 after the city issued a stop work order. Building Official Ben Carr cited the lack of a proper building permit for the structure. The house had already been built vertically and passed ten building inspections between June 16 and Sept. 18.
Carr explained the situation during the Oct. 15 city commission meeting. He noted that the site only held a floodplain development permit and a letter of no objection. Neither document authorized the construction of the residence. Carr stated that the state Department of Environmental Protection coastal construction permit did not replace the required city building permit.
The project began under Mike Alexander, who served as the city building official under a contract with Tew & Taylor. Carr took over the role on Sept. 14. In an Oct. 29 email, Carr attributed the delay to a lack of communication. He confirmed that the applicant submitted a residential building permit application on Oct. 13. The first plan review is complete, and written correction comments have been sent to the applicant. The stop work order remains in effect until all review items are resolved and fees are paid.
Frank Agnelli, co-owner of Mason Martin Builders, disputes the timeline. Agnelli said he received an email from the city on May 14 stating a permit had been issued for a single-family residence, driveway, and landscaping. The email referenced permit No. FPD-00008 with a status of approved. Agnelli believed this allowed him to proceed with construction.
Agnelli said he did not realize the approved document was a floodplain development permit rather than a building permit. He noted that he had never received a similar email regarding a floodplain permit in the past. He held that he possessed a state permit and a state letter of no objection. The discrepancy was identified during a recent roof inspection. Agnelli stated that the previous building official had conducted all prior inspections, and the issue was raised only after Carr took office.
Agnelli acknowledged that mistakes were made by both his company and the city. He is currently working through post-inspection comments regarding missing items and engineering clarifications. Agnelli plans to challenge the triple fee penalty imposed by the city. He argued that the city should have identified the missing building permit during the initial inspection.






