AdvertiseDonate
Wednesday, November 18, 2026Local news for Dallas County, Texas.
Dallas County Herald · 3838 Oak Lawn Avenue, Suite 1000, Dallas, TX 75219
Sports · National

10th Circuit Reverses NCAA Eligibility Ruling

The appeals court decision invalidates a prior order granting extra playing time to the class of 2022, though state court litigation continues.

By Daphne Turner ·

Illustration for: 10th Circuit Reverses NCAA Eligibility Ruling
Illustration generated for this article, not a news photograph.

Approximately 850 student-athletes are involved in roughly 200 state court cases that remain pending following the 10th Circuit Court of Appeals decision on Friday in Denver.

The three-judge panel ruled in Wisne v. NCAA to reverse a lower court order from July. That earlier ruling had granted players who graduated high school in 2022 a fifth year of eligibility, contrary to the NCAA's new policy. The NCAA rule allows five years of eligibility only for athletes entering the subsequent class. The July decision created uncertainty as teams signed players who had previously been sidelined.

Although the appeals court paused the lower court ruling in August, many athletes still secured roster spots due to favorable decisions in state jurisdictions. Chief legal officer Scott Bearby described the Friday decision as consistent with approaches taken by other federal appellate courts. In a memo to NCAA members, Bearby wrote that the ruling acknowledges concerns that retroactive eligibility changes can destabilize rosters and disrupt settled expectations regarding playing time.

The legal dispute centered on the definition of the player market. Judge Carolyn McHugh wrote that the plaintiffs failed to demonstrate how declaring players ineligible caused harm. The panel rejected the argument that all Division I players form a single market regardless of sport. McHugh noted that a football player would not view the 101 schools without a football program as reasonable substitutes for a roster spot.

The decision leaves the immediate situation on the field largely unchanged. Football's regular season is entering its final month, and some players, such as Texas Tech quarterback Thomas Castellanos, have moved on and off rosters based on shifting court orders. The basketball season began this week under similar conditions of uncertainty.

The NCAA secured a federal win, but the state court cases involving the 2022 class are not resolved by this specific appellate decision.

More Sports · Report a business · Got a Story?

Get Dallas County Herald in your inboxLocal news for Dallas County, Texas. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.

Get Dallas County Herald in your inboxLocal news for Dallas County, Texas. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.