Justice Department Pursues Noncitizen Voter Cases
Federal prosecutors continue criminal investigations and subpoenas against California counties despite losing key lawsuits over voter roll data.
By Salma Farouk ·

Federal prosecutors in California are moving forward with criminal investigations into alleged noncitizen voting, even after courts blocked the Department of Justice from forcing states to change how they count ballots. The administration plans to keep using grand jury subpoenas to demand records from local election officials, a tactic that has raised concerns about the scope of federal oversight in state-run elections.
U.S. Attorney General Todd Blanche stated at a press conference that the department will continue to investigate election integrity cases both criminally and civilly. He said these efforts were not expected to pause based on the recent election results. The DOJ dropped its lawsuit against California last week, but it has not withdrawn subpoenas sent to several counties, including Los Angeles, Santa Clara, and Sonoma.
The legal challenges have faced multiple setbacks. A federal judge in Washington, D.C., ruled that the Justice Department and the Department of Homeland Security lack statutory authority to distribute lists of purported noncitizens to election officials. That decision also found the government violated the Privacy Act. In a separate October ruling, another judge vacated the DOJ's project of requesting unredacted voter rolls to compare against federal databases, calling those actions unlawful.
Despite these rulings, local prosecutors are examining the cases referred by federal officials. Dan Dow, the District Attorney for San Luis Obispo, said his office received 63 potential cases and has already charged one individual. He described the process as a standard duty to uphold state law. James Williams, the county executive for Santa Clara County, noted that his office is fully prepared to continue dealing with the federal drive to identify noncitizens on the rolls.
The federal government's data has come under scrutiny for accuracy. In July, the administration claimed 250,000 noncitizens were registered in four states, a figure later described by officials as a ceiling. In mid-October, the DOJ sent California a list of 20,000 likely noncitizens. A recent analysis by the UCLA Voting Rights Project found that 42 percent of those names did not appear on California's current voter roll and that some naturalized citizens were included.
County officials have also flagged errors in the federal lists. Tricia Webber, the top election official in Santa Cruz County, reported that more than half of the 81 people listed for her county were not registered there, and some dates of birth were in the future. The DOJ has not commented on the specific subpoenas but stated it will continue to enforce federal election laws based on the facts and the law.
The next step in several counties is a review of records requested by federal attorneys. In Sonoma County, the subpoena seeks files on a specific individual alleged to have voted without citizenship and on how the county responded to federal demands to segregate ballots. In Los Angeles, the request covers how the registrar-recorders office screens for unlawful voting and how it handled federal correspondence. The department expects to appeal the recent court orders that limited its data sharing practices.






